Kafkaesque Lessons on Advice
A friend of mine, a working songwriter, recently sent out three of his songs for potential sync placements. The feedback arrived—meticulous, well-intentioned, and suffocating in its insistence that the songs could be improved. The irony, of course, is that while every line of advice seemed necessary to the reviewer, none of it truly applied to the artist’s reality. Here it is, in its full, almost bureaucratic, overwhelming detail: A Week of Mondays Lyrics: “Traffic backed up to the bridge.” “Coffee stains on Calvin Kliens.” Story on the screen, not in song. Too specific, they said, though the words were sincere. Melody: Repetitive; time changes distracting—unless intentional. Production: Bland here, overdone there; Ahs used excessively. Peaks and valleys required. Overall sync potential: Limited. Hurricane Lyrics: Good imagery, flexible, not story-tied. Melody: Average; prosody suggested. Build tension in verses, explode in chorus. Production: Big all th...